DENIED: NBCE Board Members Motion to Dismiss Colucci Lawsuit
In a blow to the nine Board Members of the National Board of Chiropractic Examiners (NBCE) being sued by Margaret Colucci DC, the Board Member they ousted, Judge Marcelo A. Kopcow denied the Motion to Dismiss submitted by NBCE and the board members.
The nine Directors named in the suit and alleging they are just "volunteers" include the Executive Committee:
Salvatore D. LaRusso DC - President
Steven Conway DC - Vice President
John C. Nab DC - Treasurer
Paul N. Morin DC
Daniel M. Cote DC - Secretary
Leroy F. Otto DC
John R. McGinnis DC
Farrel Grossman DC
Kirk Shilts DC
CLICK HERE FOR THE ORIGINAL STORY
The all male, caucasian defendants who ousted the only female NBCE Board member argued that the court lacked jurisdiction over the board members, that Colucci lacked standing to bring her claims, that the Board Members are immune from liability because (they allege) they are "volunteers" of a non profit and that Colucci could not maintain an action for declaratory judgment.
The NBCE argued that the Colorado Court lacked jurisdiction even though the NBCE headquarters is located in Colorado in part arguing that any connection to Colorado was "random and fortuitous".
That's interesting since the NBCE sued tenants of theirs in a Real Estate dispute in Colorado in 2012 and in that lawsuit the NBCE argued it had standing to sue there because it is a Colorado corporation and its mailing address is in Colorado. They are also registered as a foreign corporation in Colorado with its primary in Texas.
Of course they did not tell the current judge this.
Even without revealing this slight of hand by the NBCE, the judge in the current case wasn't buying any of it:
"The Board Members all chose to become a member of a board for a non-profit corporation with its headquarters in Colorado; all have made communications to Colorado furthering the NBCE objectives, all have created continmuous obligations between themselves and the NBCE and at least in some part attended meetings in Colorado."
The judge obviously found the NBCE's assertions incredulous stating:
"The Court is incapable of believing that communications about the operations of NBCE to Colorado, traveling to meetings in Colorado and gaining the benefit from being on the board of a non-profit with its headquarters in Colorado, is random or fortuituous. In this case the Board Members purposefully availed themselves for the purpose of condcuting business in Colorado."
In addressing her standing to sue based on fiduciary claims, the Judge tied his ruling to the relevent language in the Colorado statute governing non-profits stating she could pursue a claim for breach of fiduciary duty that proved harmful to her, even though the duty by the Board Members was owed to NBCE.
Not only that, the judged also stated:
"Further, since she could pursue the breach of fiduciary duty claim against the Board Members she could also pursue a claim against NBCE for aiding and abetting breach of a fiduciary duty."
SEE RELATED STORY REGARDING "Volunteer" Claims
The approximately $11,000.000.00 in NBCE revenue each year comes from testing students on mandated examinations they need in order to get licensed in the majority of jurisdictions. The vast majority of students get their money from student loans.
The NBCE and its Board of Directors enjoy a monopoly control over the ability of all chiropractic graduates to get a license in the United States.
CLICK BELOW for Court Filings Related to Motion to Dismiss:
- NBCE's Motion to Dismiss
- Colucci's Response to Motion
- NBCE's Response to Colucci
- Judges DENIAL of Motion to Dismiss
CLICK BELOW for more history of the NBCE.
- NBCE Board Members Claim Immunity from Colucci Lawsuit Because They are Just "Volunteers"
- Ousted NBCE Director Colucci Sues Board
- Is Student Loan Money Subsidizing the Federation of Chiropractic Licensing Boards?
- What's the Relationship Between the Florida Board, NBCE & The Florida Chiropractic Association?
- Florida Board Transfers Laws and Rules Exam to NBCE
- Florida Department of Health Recommended “Eliminating” Laws & Rules Exam
- NBCE Meeting Results in Reform
- NBCE Reform
- Top Eight Obvious NBCE Contradictions
- National Board Treasurer John Tierney,DC, Refuses Interview
- National Board Hosts Student Leadership
Blogs
- The Chiropractic Cartel: A Look Back at Bias in Accreditation and its Imact on Today's Profession
- Inside Montana's Chiropractic Monopoly: ACA & MCA's Brazen Board Takeover
- Concerns Grow About Control of the NY State Chiropractic Board by the ACA - Use of X-ray in NY Under Threat
- Mark Bronson's Conflicted Role in NBCE’s Pilot Exam: Magical Thinking and Hidden Agendas
- How One Consent Mistake Exposed a Chiropractor to Serious Risk and How to Avoid it